Friday, 8 May 2015
Can answered prayers prove God exists?
Labels:
Christianity
,
faith
,
Prayer
,
Proof of God
Let's do a thought experiment. I'll start by inventing a god, I'm going to call her Ninfinity. She is very beautiful and she will answer your prayers. Not every prayer though, she will first decide if you are deserving and if you really believe in her. If you are, she will definitely answer your prayers 100% of the time. Ninfinity is very, very powerful. In fact, she can do ANYTHING that is logically possible.
As a second step, I will persuade some Facebook friends that Ninfinity is real. This is not hard. I was top salesman for five consecutive years at Boomah's Pussy Treats. I can sell anything to anyone.
Once I have some believers they will begin their prayers to her. Ninfinity answered her first prayer with ease. A believer was late for a job interview and struggling to find a parking space. He uttered the words, "Please Ninfinity. I know you can find me a space, please find me a space." Before he finished his prayer a car pulled out right in front of him leaving a free space.
The delighted believer, posted on Facebook his success with the car parking space and something even more amazing—against his expectations he was offered the job and he had not even asked his goddess to help. Clearly she knew what he wanted—she could read his mind.
With this answered prayer, Ninfinity's list of believers grew. And so did the list of positively reported prayers. Eventually she reached more than a million Facebook followers. As her popularity grew, so did her power and people reported ever more amazing answered prayers. People survived car wrecks, terminally ill people even recovered from cancer!
Of course, Ninfinity is imaginary, so she cannot really be answering prayers. It is obvious that people are just attributing successful outcomes to her and overlooking the prayers that were not answered. Nevertheless, many people find Ninfinity totally convincing. They love her and are certain she helps them. Some people feel they couldn't live without her and they tell their children all about her powers.
...
...
If you think this story is absurd, it is not. This is actually how billions of people think. The only difference is they don't believe in my invented god, they believe in a god invented 3,500 years ago by Hebrew tribesmen. Different god; same flawed thinking process.
The problem is, an invented god cannot answer prayers. So before you attribute your answered prayers to a god, first make sure that particular god exists. Arguing that answered prayers PROVE your favourite god exists is circular reasoning—you are ASSUMING your god exists and then attributing answered prayers to it.
Flawed thinking gives invalid conclusions. No answered prayer is ever proof that a god exists. Period.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments
(
Atom
)
Nildogma, the blogga
About Me
- Nildogma
- As a 20-year-old I was insatiably curious about the world and passionate about rejecting superstitions and all kinds of false beliefs. I still am today. Sometimes when people believe things that are not true, it make little or no difference but sometimes the consequences can be disastrous and deadly. Now, I do what I can to help people improve their thinking skills, especially in how they impinge on core beliefs, such as cultural values and religious beliefs. I have an active Facebook page for which I create memes and write articles almost daily. I also engage people in on-line debates. You can find me here: https://www.facebook.com/bill.flavell.1 I lecture at universities around the world and present or debate at public meetings. I also, draw on my management consultancy background to help freethought groups, almost anywhere in the world, to get organised, develop strategy and improve their media and presentation skills. If you would like me to present at your university or for your church group or freethought group, please contact me.
Popular Posts
-
Here is a simple problem of logic. “Jack is looking at Anne, but Anne is looking at George. Jack is married but George is not. Is a marr... -
According to Christian theology, before Adam and Eve's famous serpent-induced transgressions, they were sin-free, just as God had made... -
God is said to be omniscient and unchanging. But what are the implications of these characteristics? 1) Stupid people cannot learn God ca...
-
Christianity is an elderly religion that is showing its age. It contains such huge helpings of magic and nonsense that it speaks to fewer an...
-
There is no corruption-free country in the world—every country experiences some level of corruption. But the huge differences in the leve... -
In 2012, an international team of scientists working at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) on the Swiss/French border announced they had dem... -
It was quite a stroke of luck for the Jews. Out of all the peoples in the entire world, the 12 small tribes of Israel were the chosen peo... -
Thales of Miletus In a letter to Robert Hooke, written in February 1676, the great Isaac Newton wrote, "If I have seen further it ... -
People sometimes ask me if I would like to see the end of all religion across the planet. I say it depends. It depends on what thes... -
Francis Xavier, co-founder of the Society of Jesus (Jesuits), famously said, "Give me a child until he is seven and I will give you the...
No comments :
Post a Comment